A FAIL-SAFE SOLUTION TO HAWAII’S EMBARRASSINGLY LOW VOTER-TURNOUT

By
Michele Van Hessen
-
7
6020
article top

Ward Head shoot opening day # 4Representative Gene Ward (R-Hawaii Kai – Kalama Valley) introduced legislation to increase voter turnout in the state of Hawaii, which in the last election was the lowest in the nation.

“We’ve slipped to such a low-level of voter turn-out that only about 32% of eligible voters determine who our leaders will be. It may just be time to go “down under” for some lessons from Australia where you are fined for not voting; in my bill it will cost you $100 to skip your vote on election day,“ Ward explained.

Voting has been compulsory in Australia since 1912 and appears to have reached about 94% voter turn-out in most elections. For Americans the Australian model has been rather controversial; major arguments for and against compulsory voting are:

ADVANTAGES OF MANDATORY VOTING:

  • Voting is a civic duty comparable to other mandatory duties citizens performed by citizens e.g. taxation, compulsory education, jury duty, the military draft, etc.
  • Compulsory voting teaches the benefits of political participation
  • Elected officials may more accurately the “will of the electorate” (than minority controlled democracies)
  • With mail-in voting becoming increasingly popular, mandatory voting becomes easier
  • Candidates can concentrate their campaigning energies on issues rather than encouraging voter registration and voter turn-out at the polls
  • The voter isn’t actually compelled to vote for anyone because voting is by secret ballot.

DISADVANTAGES OF MANDATORY VOTING:

  • It is undemocratic to force people to vote – an infringement of liberty
  • The ill-informed and those with little interest in politics are forced to the polls and may elect the ‘wrong people.’
  • It may increase the number of informal votes
  • It may increase the number of safe seats for incumbents with low-information voters
  • Resources must be allocated to determine whether those who failed to vote have “valid and sufficient” reasons.

In Ward’s proposed legislation, people who fail to vote are given the opportunity to be excused from voting and not be fined $100 for not voting.

“My intent is to get Hawaii back into the voting booth and is the primary reason I’m taking this Australian model into our legislature for discussion,” Ward concluded.

Comments

comments

7 COMMENTS

  2. We have the exact same problem in my country and no one it trying to find a solution to the problem. I think it's great that you've addressed the problem!

  3. this proposal by Rep. gene ward(RINO-Hawaii Kai-Kalama Valley may be unconstitutional. Forcing people to vote, will be as popular as forcing young men in the past to register for military draft and then get drafted. it is beyond belief that a republican would actually introduce this kind of authoritarian legislation. republicans are supposed to be for limited government,personal liberty. not statism. we can get better voter turn-out if we have politicians that respect our US Constitution.

  4. this proposal of compulsory voting and penalized for not voting by having to pay a $100 fine is nothing more than a tax.it istroubling that a republican legislator would propose this. It is as bad as Obamacare,which is also a tax.

Comments are closed.